Avatar
Official Artist
Mark Allen
Director , Screenwriter , Composer
542,311 views| 255  Posts

My Story Rebellion

When I graduated from college, I pronounced to anyone that would listen that I wanted to make films that had no story.  I had become so tired of story being proclaimed as "king" - and was a bit of an artistic rebel and felt this was the cause I would champion.

After creating a few projects under this philosophy - I realized that no matter what I did, I could not get away from story.  It was around this time that I realized that story is built into our genetic code  Just as we might look at clouds and recognize faces - we look at events and see stories.

If you place two images one after the other to someone, they begin to relate them.  This has been used by propagandists for as long as it was possible to put photographs in sequence.   The cave paintings told stories.  Faces tell stories.  When we sleep, the one part of our brain that never rests it the part that makes sense out of everything - and to do that - it takes whatever random left over memories come up and turns them into stories.

We can, however, escape a lot of the artifice that has been put on stories.  While "The hero with a thousand faces" and "Stealing Fire From the Gods" are two books that both do an excellent job of discussing how as humans we have certain archetypes which we identify with and therefore see again and again in the history of our stories, mythologies, religion, and entertainment - this observation does not mean, though, that every single movie needs to follow the "Hero's Journey."

What I should have been rebelling against was not story - but the generification of story which is why so many movies feel like the same movie.  The various elements of movies have become so required and expected, that every most movies feels the same.  Certainly most movies that get enough marketing behind them for us to actually know about them do.The glory of independent filmmaking is that there is no executive that is going to require that you include a certain beat on a certain page or that you follow any strict rules of story. With the freedom from external requirements being their best tool, I hope that independent filmmakers take the opportunity to make story their own, not just make their own stories.

almost 16 years ago 0 likes  10 comments  0 shares
Photo 22998
Jaine - those are really interesting examples because I DID feel both those films felt very generic to me. They were not necessarily the classic "Hero's Journey" - but the beats in them were so generic I did not feel pulled into them personally - but I also felt a little bit like they were trying too hard to be "real life" and not being it and I guess overall the movies didn't gel for me. Memento was one of my favorite movies of all time for this very reason. It really approached story differently and it's in own way. I think there are lots of movies which are totally engaging yet don't feel so incredibly formulaic. Two Ang Lee films jump to mind - Brokeback Mountain and Lus Caution. Obviously the movie "Crash" was doing it's own thing. Pulp Fiction for sure as was Resevoir Dogs (Tarrantino, both). Babel was carving it's own path. All of those films were very well received.
almost 16 years ago
Photo 34291
"Story" itself is innocent. Even "a Hero's Journey" is innocent. It is indeed when a story or a journey is told in a very crafty contrived manner that makes it generic and mediocre. It really depends on the filmmaker itself to make it unconventional without "trying too much". Hard task for you, Mark.
almost 16 years ago
Photo 22998
I should clarify that "The Hero's Journey" is a very very specific outline of a plot - it gets very very specific - but the basic 12 steps are: 1. Ordinary World. 2. Call to Adventure 3. Refusal of the Call 4. Meeting with the Mentor 5. Crossing the First Threshold 6. Tests, Allies, Enemies 7. Approach to the innermost Cave 8. Ordeal (the ultimate crisis) 9. Reward (some type of epiphany that gives the hero the ability to win) 10. The Road Back (Returning to finish the fight) 11. Resurection (Climax) 12. Return with the Elixer (or prize or solution) And I'm not saying you can't make movies with this outline - in fact, this outline of stories was derived from thousands of mythological stories throughout the history of human story telling - I just feel like people have begun to use this outline in movies so strictly that all movies start feeling the same
almost 16 years ago
Photo 34291
Mmm... I remember reading that book "The Writers Journey" asking exactly the same question you've raised... Funnily enough then I went to Michael Hauge's seminar talking about "Six Stage Plot Structure". These two structures were very very similar, except the terminology. Don't you think so? Not all movie that followed those rules turned out to be the best seller. And some movies that didn't follow those structures turned out to be very popular (Memento like you suggested, which by the way, got the Bollywood remake which earned the highest box office to date in India). There's just no magic formula there isn't it?
almost 16 years ago
Photo 22998
celine - I think the closest thing to a magic formula is that if you can set up a series of compelling dilemmas - you can own your audience's curiosity and attention.
almost 16 years ago

About

Learn More

Languages Spoken
english
Location (City, Country)
Los Angeles, United States
Gender
male
Member Since
April 13, 2007