Avatar
官方艺术家
卡如飞
主持人
3,661,361 查看| 3,111  更新

Blood Brothers Review

In addition to the red carpet premiere festivities,  we also got to actually see the movie too.  I've been looking forward to it for a while, but I had also heard from a few people that there were some problems with the movie... so I went into the screening with tempered expectations.

But I have been interested in the 1920's-30's era gangster period since I first saw Zhang Yimou's 'Shanghai Triad'   (or was it since I first saw ' Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom'?),  so I knew from the production stills that were published before the movie that the styling and period sets would be interesting enough to me no matter what.

At its face, the story is relatively simple and its been told many times.  Young guys from the country go to the big city to try and make their fortunes.  Inevitably one of them is more willing to do whatever it takes to succeed more than the others...  power corrupts and all that... you've seen this before.

It gets a bit more complicated, but I'll skip over the double love triangle details and cut to the chase:

Hsu Chi looked gorgeous in just about every scene.

As I mentioned,  I was predisposed to just enjoy the sets, the costumes and the dance numbers...  so for me, this was enough to enjoy the movie, but maybe thats not enough for some of you!

Daniel, Chang Cheng and Hsu Chi do a good job, but I think Liu Ye's character was the most interesting to me... I just wish it had been developed better.

Which brings me to the downside: The storytelling (and/or editing) come off as a bit choppy and lacking.  For example: You can't ever tell how much or how little time has passed since the previous scenes and the character development also seems to have been cut short.  Characters' motivations aren't really explained or explored...  Some stuff (like that movie studio scene!)  randomly comes out of left field and is never really explained.  (Tan's background as a music video director may explain this?!?)

Also in a few key spots the camera work is a bit confusing - rather than having a far off shot showing the relative position of two sides of a gun fight, they just have close ups... you don't know if they're 10 feet apart or 50...  (it reminded me a bit of the ending of 'Yamato no Otoko', where they obviously didn't want to spend the money on sets or CG so they avoid showing more than a 20'x20' area at a single time). :-P

For me, the costumes, styling, music and performances  were good enough to overcome these shortcomings,  but maybe not everyone will agree with me. :-P

I'll give it a 7/10.  OK,  tomorrow is a few 'after party' pics! stay tuned!  ;-)

ps - Its a John Woo production,  so you know they're going to have to have a big gun battle at the end...  bye bye fancy set! :-P

大约 17 年 前 0 赞s  21 评论s  0 shares
45862083 0af2fd4d5d
rancho: she was Daniel's 'back home girl'... her character wasn't very developed either... :-P w-bird: good question... I think 'Infernal Affairs' definitely is the best film from the past 5 years. I like a lot of Derek Yee's movies too... Full Throttle, Viva Erotica, c'est la vie, mon cherie, one night in mongkok. they're not perfect but they're pretty good.
大约 17 年 ago
45862083 0af2fd4d5d
actually you can see it in like 2 or 3 weeks. its showing at the Toronto film festival! rush out and get tickets. :-P
大约 17 年 ago
45862083 0af2fd4d5d
no, its not from a novel, its loosely based on Woo's 'bullet to the head' and/or a 1973 movie also called 'blood brothers'... like i said the 'friends faced with violence and temptation' thing is not new...
大约 17 年 ago
45862083 0af2fd4d5d
w-bird: oh you're a film student! actually i like all kinds of movies, even if they're not really good (comedies, etc). its actually worse when they try hard and still do a bad job! :-P
大约 17 年 ago
Li tong 2014 2 photo by fion cao
Will go and watch this movie soon! xx
大约 17 年 ago
45862083 0af2fd4d5d
i don't think its her really singing though. she dances too...
大约 17 年 ago
45862083 0af2fd4d5d
ha. ok, i'll have to ask for 3rd party confirmation...
大约 17 年 ago

关于

I work at alivenotdead.com. Please check out my blogs and leave a comment!

阅读全文

语言
English,Armenian,Japanese,Mandarin
位置(城市,国家)以英文标示
Hong Kong
性别
Male
加入的时间
April 13, 2007